Space and Astronomy Atlas

How The Universe Works
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme
Open Question

Were the positive results from the Viking landers' biological experiments evidence of microbial life on Mars, or can they be explained by non-biological chemistry in the Martian soil?

Facts
Why It Is Open
The Viking landers' Labeled Release experiment produced results initially read as consistent with biological metabolism, but most scientists later concluded the same results were more likely caused by non-biological, highly oxidizing chemical reactions in the Martian soil. No follow-up mission has definitively settled which explanation is correct. 1
What Would Resolve This
A mission capable of directly detecting biological molecules or organisms in Martian soil, rather than inferring metabolism indirectly from gas-exchange chemistry, or a complete explanation of the Labeled Release results from soil chemistry alone that leaves no ambiguity. 1
Discipline Needed
Astrobiology and planetary soil chemistry 1
Question Kind
Mechanism 1
Question Status
Open 1
Reader Facing
Yes 1
Open Question

The Viking landers' Labeled Release experiment produced results initially read as consistent with biological metabolism, but most scientists later concluded the same results were more likely caused by non-biological, highly oxidizing chemical reactions in the Martian soil. No follow-up mission has definitively settled which explanation is correct.

What would resolve this A mission capable of directly detecting biological molecules or organisms in Martian soil, rather than inferring metabolism indirectly from gas-exchange chemistry, or a complete explanation of the Labeled Release results from soil chemistry alone that leaves no ambiguity.
OpenAstrobiology and planetary soil chemistryViking program (Wikipedia)
Connections

Question On

Source Wikipedia (space and spaceflight articles)
Sources
1. Wikipedia (space and spaceflight articles)
Wikimedia Foundation
Viking program (Wikipedia)
Viking program, Biological experiments sectionView the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.